''Disagreement among my ummah is a mercy''
1. This is not a sahih hadeeth, not even a hadith but an athar of Umar bin Abdul Aziz.
1. This is not a sahih hadeeth, not even a hadith but an athar of Umar bin Abdul Aziz.
2. Ibn Hazm had asked: If the disagreement among the ummat is a mercy, so is agreement among them a trouble?
3. May be the meaning can be sahih or right if that disagreement flourishing variety of good ideas and opinions, in condition all of them are not contradict with al-Kitab and al-Sunnah.
4. Or it's acceptable if this disagreement correcting what is wrong and astray..
5. But we still cannot claim this hadeeth is from our Prophet..the right meaning is not necessarily shows the autheticity of hadeeth..how many texts containing perfect meanings, but they are not prophetic words at all..
3. May be the meaning can be sahih or right if that disagreement flourishing variety of good ideas and opinions, in condition all of them are not contradict with al-Kitab and al-Sunnah.
4. Or it's acceptable if this disagreement correcting what is wrong and astray..
5. But we still cannot claim this hadeeth is from our Prophet..the right meaning is not necessarily shows the autheticity of hadeeth..how many texts containing perfect meanings, but they are not prophetic words at all..
Няма коментари:
Публикуване на коментар